2014

HomeWashington Letter2014 ▶ FDA Extends Comment Period on Tobacco Rule to Aug. 8
FDA Extends Comment Period on Tobacco Rule to Aug. 8

June 2014

The ATS asks all members to send comments supporting the U.S. Food and Drug Administration proposal to regulate all tobacco products. The FDA has extended the deadline to submit comments to Aug. 8, 2014. The time to submit comments is now and the information below will assist you in submitting comments. Please click here to submit prepared comments on this proposed rule.

The proposal released earlier this year by the FDA would broaden its authority over cigarettes to include all other tobacco products. Specifically, the FDA is proposing:

  • Prohibition of the sales of tobacco products to anyone under the age of 18
  • Prohibition of vending-machine sales (except in places where only adults have access)
  • Registration by all manufactures with the FDA, including a list of all tobacco products they sell
  • Disclosure of ingredients by manufacturers to the FDA
  • Elimination of free sampling of all tobacco products
  • Good manufacturing practice requirements
  • Premarket review for any "new" tobacco product
  • Premarket review of any product wishing to make a "modified risk or harm" claim
  • User fees for all newly deemed products

While the ATS supports the above proposed actions, we are concerned the proposal is weak in other areas. Most notably, the proposed rule does not:

  • Ban sweetened or candy flavored tobacco products
  • Require child proof e-cigarette cartridges
  • Ban Internet sales of tobacco products

Premium Cigar Exemption:Most concerning, the proposed rule seeks comment on whether "premium cigars" – defined as hand-rolled whole leaf cigars costing more than $10 – should be exempt from any FDA regulations. The ATS strongly opposes this proposal.
To date, over 34,000 public comments have been submitted. The majority of the 34,000 comments have come from tobacco users who urge the FDA to exempt premium cigars from regulation, provide light oversight to e-cigarette products, or both.

Instructions for Submitting Comments

  1. Please click here to submit prepared comments on this proposed rule.
  2. Cut and paste the prepared comments below into the comment section of the online form.
  3. Complete any necessary fields with your contact information and required information.
  4. Click "Continue."

Prepared Comments:

Docket No. FDA-2013-N-0189 and RIN 0910-AG38

As a health care provider, I know the cost of diseases caused by tobacco. I see it in my patients every day, in the needless addiction, disease and death caused by tobacco use. That is why I support the Food and Drug Administration moving forward with strong regulations for all tobacco products. Specifically, I support FDA's proposals to require:

  • Registration by all manufactures with FDA, including a list of all tobacco products they sell.
  • Disclosure of ingredients by manufacturers to FDA.
  • Prohibiting sales of tobacco products to anyone under the age of 18.
  • Eliminating free sampling of all tobacco products.
  • Good manufacturing practice requirements.
  • Premarket review for any "new" tobacco product.

While I support these policies, I am concerned the proposed rule did not go far enough. I urge FDA to consider:

  • Banning sweetened or candy-flavored tobacco products.
  • Requiring childproof e-cigarette cartridges.
  • Banning internet sales of tobacco products.

And under no circumstances should FDA exempt "premium cigars" from FDA regulations. While the health risks of cigars are different than those of cigarettes, cigars still cause disease and premature death. FDA should regulate cigars and all other tobacco products.

Despite the progress we as a nation have taken in reducing tobacco use, tobacco is still the single largest cause of preventable death in the U.S., killing more than 1,300 people each day. We look forward to FDA moving forward with rules to reduce the addiction, disease and death caused by tobacco.

Last Reviewed: October 2017